My ‘Perfect Christian Fiancé’ Had Rules for Me That He Didn’t Follow Himself — The Day I Caught Him Kissing Another Woman Broke Everything

When Hazel calls for a man who calls himself godly, she's prepared to follow his rules in the name of love. But the deeper she bends, the more she begins to break, until one devastating moment shatters everything. What follows is her quiet, powerful return to truth, freedom, and herself.

I was 25 when I thought I'd finally found someone good.

His name was Elias. He was 27, calm, handsome, and carried himself with quiet certainty, the kind of presence that made people lean in a little closer... and listen a little longer.

A smiling woman wearing a green dress | Source: Midjourney

We met at a small Bible study group hosted in a friend's apartment. He stood out immediately. He was always quoting scripture, and always steering the room back to God. He always seemed too sure of everything.

For the first time in years, I let myself picture a future with someone. A life built on faith, shared values, and peace. It all felt safe and solid, like maybe this time, I wouldn't be left bruised or disappointed.

Elias made it seem like he was above all that, like he answered to something higher than impulse or ego.

A woman reading a book | Source: Midjourney

But looking back, I can see how I ignored the unease. The way his praise always came with conditions. The way he talked about other women, too loud, too flashy, too much.

"You don't want to be the kind of woman men stare at, Hazel," he said after a service one day. "You want to be the one they respect."

At the time, I thought it was wisdom. Maybe even love.

A smiling man standing outside a church | Source: Midjourney

It wasn't long before Elias sat me down and explained what he called the "guardrails of a holy courtship." He never used the word rules, but that's exactly what they were, a list of expectations that left little room for me to be anything but small.

He began carefully, as if he were offering a gift. He even made me a cup of tea and offered me chocolate-covered shortbread.

"Hazel," he said, "I need you to take this conversation seriously."

A cup of tea and a plate of shortbread | Source: Midjourney

I nodded. I didn't know where he was going with this, but I wanted to see what he had in store for our lives.

"There will be no physical contact before marriage, Hazel," he said. "Not even kissing. That kind of intimacy is reserved for your husband in private."

"Wait, Elias... not even a kiss?"

He smiled like he'd rehearsed that very moment a hundred times before.

A man sitting on a couch | Source: Midjourney

"It's for your own good, sweetheart. Kissing leads to other things, and we don't want to fall into temptation, do we? This is about protecting you, and about honoring God."

Something in me hesitated then, but I said nothing.

Then came the rest.

A pensive woman sitting on a couch | Source: Midjourney

"Your skirts should fall below the ankle. Sleeves should be down to the wrist," he said. "Modesty is a gift to the men around you, Hazel. It's a sign of your respect for their struggle."

Struggle? For a split second, he looked like a stranger to me. And even worse, he wasn't angry. He wasn't raising his voice. That somehow made it more unsettling.

"No tight clothing. Nothing form-fitting. As for makeup... if you must wear it, keep it minimal. A woman's beauty shouldn't distract from her character."

A pensive man wearing a navy shirt | Source: Midjourney

He paused, maybe to let it all land, maybe to see if I would object. I just nodded, slow and uncertain. My mouth felt dry. My thoughts were racing, but I kept trying to tell myself this was fine.

This was devotion. This was discipline.

Still, Elias continued.

"No close friendships with men. Emotional or personal conversations are dangerous. The devil thrives in emotional connections outside of marriage. You know that, right?"

A woman sitting with her hand on her head | Source: Midjourney

I looked down at my hands.

"No worldly media. No movies, music, or social platforms until the Church deems it fit. The rest will corrupt your spirit."

"But, Elias, I — " I began.

He gently raised a hand.

"Hazel, I know you think it's harmless. But I'm trying to protect our future."

A frowning man sitting on a couch | Source: Midjourney

He went on.

"When we're married, I expect you to stay home. I'll provide for us. Your calling will be raising our children and caring for our home."

"What about work? I mean, I adore my job, Elias."

He gave a small, understanding smile.

A woman standing in a kitchen | Source: Pexels

"I know. But the world teaches women to chase independence instead of peace. You'll see. This is better. This is so much better."

"And lastly," he added, his tone softening as if offering romance, "we'll pray together every morning and every night. That's how a godly couple stays connected."

"Wow... that's a lot," I said, letting out an awkward laugh.

A woman standing in a living room | Source: Midjourney

"Hazel, this is a narrow path, and I want to lead you toward holiness. There's nothing wrong with living life the right way, and that's exactly what we're going to do."

And somehow, despite the ache in my chest and the voice screaming in my head, I said yes.

I followed everything he asked.

I boxed up my jeans and makeup, leaving only mascara and lip balm. I deleted my Spotify playlists and packed away books I loved. I stopped watching the shows that used to comfort me after long days at work.

A cellphone opened to Spotify | Source: Unsplash

I said no to brunches. I skipped birthdays. I declined coffee with friends who didn't "live by the Word."

When Elias spoke about obedience, I thought he meant faith. When he said submission was love, I tried to believe him.

Each morning, I pulled my hair back into a low, tidy bun and buttoned up long, shapeless blouses. I reminded myself this was what a godly woman looked like. I prayed with Elias on speakerphone twice a day, even when I was exhausted, even when I hadn't slept well, and when I felt like God had stopped listening to me.

A woman standing in a kitchen | Source: Midjourney

There was a night, just two weeks into our engagement, when we played a Bible trivia game with friends. Elias mispronounced "Nebuchadnezzar" so badly it sounded like gibberish, and I burst out laughing — really laughing. I couldn't help it. Everyone else chuckled too.

Even Elias smiled, briefly.

But later, in the car, his voice changed.

A person reading a Bible | Source: Pexels

"Hazel, that wasn't appropriate," he said, not looking at me. "Women shouldn't draw attention to themselves like that."

"I didn't mean anything by it," I said quickly. "It was just... funny."

"I'm not angry, sweetheart," he replied calmly. "But we're setting an example. People look to us. You don't want to be remembered for how loud your laugh is."

A woman sitting in a car | Source: Midjourney

I stared out the window the rest of the ride home, quietly scolding myself.

"He's right, Hazel. This is what discipline looks like. You're growing. Evolving. This is love."

Two months passed. We still hadn't kissed, not even once.

When I finally brought it up — gently, carefully — Elias shook his head.

A frowning man sitting on a couch | Source: Midjourney

"We aren't like other couples. We're saving ourselves completely. That's what makes it sacred."

I didn't argue. I just nodded and swallowed the ache.

"I wasn't always like this," he said once, almost to himself. "I saw what unfaithfulness did to my family, and I promised I'd lived differently. My father just... went too far."

But slowly, things started to feel... off. His phone would buzz, and he'd excuse himself to the hallway. If I walked in too quickly, I'd see him closing apps or clearing messages.

A cellphone on a table | Source: Midjourney

"Is everything okay?" I asked him once.

"It's just ministry stuff, Hazel."

I believed him. I wanted to believe him. But the quiet doubt began to settle in my chest like cold water.

And then, one Friday night, everything shattered.

A woman leaning against a wall | Source: Midjourney

I had gone to a friend's apartment for a quiet book club meeting — tea, paperbacks, nothing wild. It was one of the few things I still allowed myself to enjoy, and I clung to those small moments of normalcy like air.

When it ended early, I decided to walk home. The air was cool, and the streets were quiet.

As I passed the community center where Elias volunteered on Friday nights, I noticed the lights were still on. The front doors were propped open. I wasn't even planning to look, but something made me glance toward the front steps.

A woman walking on a sidewalk | Source: Midjourney

And that's when I saw him.

He was kissing another woman. And it wasn't a polite kiss... it wasn't a one-time slip.

No, this was intimate. It seemed familiar. One of Elias' hands rested on her waist, the other cupped her cheek. She leaned into him like it was the most natural thing in the world, and she was laughing — quietly, softly, like they'd done this before.

A silhouette of a couple | Source: Pexels

I stopped walking.

My brain couldn't process what I was seeing. My body went cold. My feet felt cemented to the sidewalk.

My fiancé — the man who told me a kiss would dishonor God, who said holding hands was too close to temptation, and who scolded me for drawing attention to myself — stood on church property kissing another woman like none of it mattered.

"No way," I whispered out loud.

An emotional woman standing on a sidewalk | Source: Midjourney

I took a shaky step forward, squinting. This was definitely Elias. And the woman — I recognized her too. She worked at the coffee shop near my office. I'd seen her at a service once. Elias had called her "too flirtatious" and told me to avoid her completely.

Now she was kissing him.

"You're bad, Eli," she teased, pulling away from him, giggling loudly.

"You bring it out of me..." he said, tracing the curve of her jaw with his thumb.

A man touching a woman's ear | Source: Pexels

My stomach dropped.

I turned and walked away before either of them saw me. I didn't cry. I didn't scream. I just kept walking, one step at a time, as if I were watching someone else's life unravel in slow motion.

The next morning, I called him. I hadn't rehearsed what to say. I didn't need to. My heart was still pounding from what I'd seen, and the weight of it had settled into my chest like wet cement.

A woman talking on a phone | Source: Midjourney

He picked up on the second ring.

"Elias," I said quickly, trying to get it all out before I caved. "I saw you last night. I saw you kissing her outside the community center."

There was a pause. A little too long.

"That's not what it looked like." His words tripped over themselves, panicked and clumsy.

I gripped the phone tighter.

The exterior of a community center | Source: Unsplash

"It's exactly what it looked like. You made me follow all your rules. You wouldn't even let me kiss you. And now you're out there kissing another woman like none of it matters?"

"I... Hazel, I was lonely," he sighed. "I wasn't thinking clearly. You've been distant lately."

My mouth went dry.

"I've been distant?! Elias, I gave up everything for you. My friends, my job, even my voice. I did everything you asked so I could be worthy of you. And now you're blaming me?"

A man talking on a phone | Source: Midjourney

"I didn't mean it like that," he muttered. "You're twisting this. You're making this ugly."

"No, Elias!" I said firmly. "I'm finally seeing it clearly. You're not holy. You're just a fraud."

He tried again, his voice softer.

"I made a mistake. Doesn't everybody? I'm only human, Hazel. Haven't you ever — "

I ended the call before he could finish. That was the last time I heard his voice.

A woman leaning against a kitchen counter | Source: Midjourney

I didn't report him to the church. I didn't need to do anything, because soon, fate intervened.

A few weeks later, a friend texted me. Someone else had come forward. The board launched an investigation. Elias was asked to step down. Naturally, his reputation unraveled, not because of me, but because the truth had been waiting to surface.

Then the calls started.

A cellphone on a table | Source: Midjourney

"Please don't cancel the engagement," Charlotte, Elias' mother, begged in one voicemail. "He needs you. He's so lost without you."

I didn't respond.

So she came to my door.

Her eyes were red when I opened it, her face lined with worry. She held her hands together like she didn't know what else to do with them.

An emotional older woman | Source: Midjourney

"He's my son," she said softly. "He's ashamed. He's struggling. Please... don't give up on him, Hazel. Please, my darling."

I looked at Charlotte and saw someone who had probably been asked to stay quiet her whole life... who had probably followed rules that didn't protect her.

"I'm not giving up," I said. "I'm choosing myself. I won't marry a man who makes rules he doesn't follow. I won't live in silence so someone else can pretend they're righteous."

A woman standing at a front door | Source: Midjourney

She blinked hard, then nodded. She didn't say another word.

That night, I returned my engagement ring. I held it in my hand for a moment, then let it go.

For a while, the grief came in waves. I cried for the version of myself I buried just to fit into Elias's mold. I cried for the girl who thought obedience would earn her love. Who believed that shrinking herself would bring her closer to God.

An upset woman lying on her bed | Source: Midjourney

But slowly, it got easier.

One morning, I woke up and noticed that sun didn't feel heavy anymore. I brewed coffee and played the music I'd once deleted without question. I sang along while making breakfast. I laughed, loud and unfiltered, and didn't apologize for it.

Some mornings I still heard his voice in my head, disguised as wisdom. But I was learning to separate fear from faith. I was learning to trust my own voice again.

A woman busy in a kitchen | Source: Midjourney

Then one afternoon, I saw Elias at the grocery store. He was standing near the apples, looking smaller than I remembered. His eyes found mine before I could look away.

"Hazel," he said softly. "I've been praying that I'd run into you."

I nodded politely but didn't speak.

"I've... I've been meaning to apologize. I made mistakes. Big ones. But I hope, in time, you'll find it in your heart to forgive me. That's what the Lord would want."

A man standing in a grocery store | Source: Midjourney

"God may want forgiveness, Elias. But He also wants truth. You never offered me that, not once."

He started to say something else, but I was already turning away.

I walked down the spice aisle and picked up a packet of dried chili flakes. I passed the freezer section and grabbed a fillet of hake. Then I found a can of coconut milk — my favorite brand. I was making dinner that night. Something I wanted. Something I liked.

An aisle in a grocery store | Source: Pexels

As I moved through the aisles, I felt the silent peace of someone who had nothing to prove.

I thought of Matthew — the man I'm seeing now. The one who prays with me not because it's demanded, but because we both want to feel God together. The one who tells me I'm beautiful — not because I'm modest, but because I'm alive.

With Matthew, I can laugh as loud as I want. I can wear what I love, watch what I enjoy, dance in the kitchen, and have opinions without walking on eggshells.

A smiling man standing outside | Source: Midjourney

He doesn't measure my worth in silence or sacrifice.

He just sees me. And he loves me.

That night, I cooked hake in coconut milk and chili flakes. I poured a glass of wine. I lit a few candles. And I thanked God for giving me back to myself.

A few weeks later, I opened my laptop and signed up for a weekend writing workshop. I used to dream about telling stories that mattered... now I was finally letting myself try.

A tray of food on a kitchen counter | Source: Midjourney

If you've enjoyed this story, here's another one for you: When Nadia's husband refuses to split daycare costs for their son, she quietly stops carrying the weight of their so-called partnership. What unfolds is a sharp, emotional reckoning about motherhood, marriage, and the price of being taken for granted...

This story is a work of fiction inspired by real events. Names, characters, and details have been altered. Any resemblance is coincidental. The author and publisher disclaim accuracy, liability, and responsibility for interpretations or reliance. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.